Eyebrows frame the face, and achieving the perfect shape and fullness is a common beauty goal. While Benefit's Precisely, My Brow Pencil is a popular choice, its price point can be a deterrent. This article explores cruelty-free, more affordable alternatives that offer similar results. The search for the ideal dupe focuses on key factors: preciseness, smoothness, natural-looking results, and shade range.
Natural brows are always in style. For those with sparse areas due to overplucking or other reasons, filling in brows is essential for a polished look. This exploration exclusively considers cruelty-free brands, limiting the options but aligning with ethical beauty standards.
When evaluating potential dupes, several factors are considered:
Several brands offer eyebrow pencils that aim to replicate the effects of Benefit's Precisely, My Brow Pencil. Here's a breakdown of some popular contenders:
While Colourpop is not strictly a drugstore brand, its accessibility at Ulta makes it a convenient option for many. The Brow Boss Pencil has a small, rounded tip and requires some warming up for smooth application. Once warmed, it allows for a light-handed, feathering technique.
Read also: Get Fluffy Brows with Benefit
Previously priced at $5 USD, Colourpop has since raised the price. The line offers a limited shade range. Past purchases included a brunette shade that was deemed acceptable but slightly warm. Subsequent purchases included light brown and dark brown shades, both of which were considered passable, although the light brown leaned warmer.
The Covergirl Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil line has only four shades. The shade 710 Soft Brown was tested and found to be warm-toned but dark enough to use. Its color is fairly close to Colourpop's Brow Boss in dark brown. The warmth of the shade can make the brow tail appear less natural.
The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil is the most affordable option among those tested. This line boasts eight shades with swatches indicating undertones ranging from warm to cool. However, the pencil is dry, less precise than the Covergirl option, and requires more pressure during application, which can tug at the skin.
The shade tested had a reddish tint that did not match the natural brow color. While a darker shade might be a better fit, the initial impression was that it looked muddy. Despite the initial experience, past experiences with this pencil in different shades have been positive.
Kokie Cosmetics Precision Brow Pencil line also has only four shades. While the undertones are not readily apparent due to the lack of swatches, the pencil is precise and creamy, allowing for a light-handed application. The shade 555 Warm Brown appears similar to Covergirl's color when swatched but looks warm and reddish in photos.
Read also: Comprehensive Eyebrow Piercing Guide
Morphe Micro Brow Pencil is easily accessible and available in-store and online at Ulta. With 10 shades, it offers a wider selection than many other brands. The shade Latte has a cool undertone and was deemed a good fit. The pencil is slightly dry, requiring multiple strokes and pressure for pigment to show, which compromises its preciseness. The results were described as half natural and half muddy.
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil line features eight shades, but determining the undertones of each shade can be challenging. Despite swatches being available, the shades tested appeared warm, despite not seeming so initially. This pencil is creamy, precise, and allows for the feathering technique to create a natural look. It has been a long-time purchase, but the search for the perfect shade continues.
Benefit Cosmetics offers a wide array of eyebrow products designed to cater to various needs. The brand's dedication to eyebrow solutions is evident in its extensive product line.
Precisely, My Brow Pencil Ultra-fine brow defining pencil by Benefit is a favorite for its ease of use and ability to create natural-looking brows. It's particularly effective for filling in sparse areas without creating a heavy, unnatural look. However, the price tag of $26.00 per pencil can be a deterrent. Additionally, it can be difficult to determine when the product is running low, leading to unexpected depletion.
Goof Proof Brow Pencil requires less time and it's a bit less detailed (still precise enough which makes for a great eyebrow tool when you are in a rush or your eyebrows are in overall decent shape).
Read also: Causes and Relief for Eyebrow Pain
Gimme Brow+ volumizing mousse didn't really didn't do much when it comes to eyebrow hair appearance (it's more of a finishing product that you apply after a pomade/pencil/shadow). Some users find it effective for adding dimension to naturally well-shaped eyebrows.
24-HR Brow Setter Brow Gel is a clear gel with a flexible, flake-free formula that helps keep eyebrows in place. It is a good alternative to Sephora Brow Freeze which basically has the same idea behind it.
Joah Fine Point Brow Pencil is a lower priced close enough copy of a higher priced item. While they’re often nearly identical, there are some products that look similar but don’t match the quality. That’s not the case with Joah Fine Point Brow Pencil which is actually prefer to Precisely, My Brow.
One recurring theme in the search for the perfect dupe is the importance of undertones. Many drugstore brands tend to have warm undertones, making it challenging to find a suitable match for those with cooler undertones.
tags: #benefit #eyebrow #pencil #dupe
